1949- Dave Newcombe

1950- Walt Dropo

1951- Gil McDougald

1952- Harry Byrd

1953- Harvey Kuenn

1954- Burleigh Grimes

1955- Herb Score

1956- Luis Aparicio

1957- Tony Kubek

1958- Albie Pearson

1959- Bob Anderson

1960- Ron Hanson

1961- Don Schwall

1962- Tom Tresh

1963- Gary Peters

1964- Tony Olivia

1965- Curt Blefary

1966- Tommy Agee

1967- Rod Carew

1968- Stan Bahnsen

1969- Lou Pinella

1970- Thurman Munson

1971- Chris Chambliss

1972- Carlton Fisk

1973- Al Bumbry

1974- Mike Hargrove

1975- Fred Lynn

1976- Mark Fidrych

1977- Eddie Murray

1978- Lou Whitaker

1979- John Castino

1980- Joe Charboneau

1981- Dave Righetti

1982- Cal Ripken Jr.

1983- Ron Kittle

1984- Alvin Davis

1985- Ozzie Guillen

1986- Jose Canseco

1987- Mark McGwire

1988-Walt Weiss

1989- Greg Olsen

1990- Sandy Alomar

1991- Chuck Knoblauch

1992- Pat Listach

1993- Tim Salmon

1994- Billy Hamelin

1995- Marty Cordova

1996- Derek Jeter

1997- Nomar Garciaparra

1998- Ben Grieve

1999- Carlos Beltran

2000- Kazuhiro Sasaki