a more perfect union
an exploration of american democracy
 

 

Home
History of Democracy
Theories of Government
Models of Democracy
    Participatory Model
    Protective Model
    Developmental Model
    Pluralist Model
Challenges to Democracy
    Radical Individualism
    Inequality
    Representation
Sociologists on Government     Max Weber
    Robert Michels
    Marx and Engels
    Pareto and Mosca
    Alexis de Tocqueville
Works Cited

 

Please note that all pages are written in the Modern Language Association Format.  For more information, see MLA Format Defined.

Protective Model

The most basic model of indirect democracy is the Protective Democracy. In this model, the primary function of the government is to protect the liberty of the citizens. The citizenry plays a passive role; representatives speak for their constituents. British political philosopher Jeramy Bentham disagreed with the Participatory model, saying that citizens were, by nature, self-interested and competitive and thus would be watchful against government officials infringing upon their liberties. The citizens, Bentham reasoned, would check the power of representatives not acting in their best interest by voting them out of office. Protective Democrats felt that government should extend only as far as necessary to protect individuals’ rights and a liberal, capitalist, market society. "Democracy exists so that free competitive individuals may have and enjoy a maximum of freedom to pursue material wealth" and other objectives, according to Participatory Democrats (Hudson 10-12). Bentham and British political philosopher, James Mill called for limitations on the power of the government, so that it would not behave tyrannically. This can be achieved through the separation of powers, federalism, and bicameralism. Protective Democracy also ensures political equality and equal protection under the law. In summary, it is a minimal government existing solely to protect the liberties of a nation’s citizens (Fragoza; Hudson 10-12).

A More Perfect Union was created by ThinkQuest Team 26466: Eric Barr, Taylor Rankin, and John Baird.
This website is a ThinkQuest entry focusing on the various facets of American democracy.
©1999 ThinkQuest Team 26466; use of website implies agreement with terms of copyright.