At Any Time...
Ethical Dilemma
History
Today
Other Countries
Current Problems
Advertising
Books
Internet
Journalism
Media
Propaganda
Book Stacks: Banned
Books Exhibit
Multimedia presentation on literacy censorship.
Humanities
Interactive
Well-presented collection of exhibitions.
Electronic Privacy Information
Center
Watchdog group for personal rights in the Information
Age.
Recreational Software Advisory
Council
Provides content ratings standards for television and
video game industries.
|
Censorship is the suppression of information:
thoughts, ideas, opinions, and beliefs. Authority figures, such as governments,
censor information they feel shouldn’t be communicated to the public.
At Any
Time...
Information can be censored at any time. The person who communicates
the information may "censor" him or her self by avoiding inappropriate
information entirely, not because they want to but in fear of punishment.
The information may be censored after it is written but before public distribution,
or at least before the entire public has enough time to reach it. Finally,
the communicator of the indecent information may be punished following
its dissemination (distribution).
Ethical
Dilemma
Censorship is among the most intriguing ethical
dilemmas in today’s society. The basic concepts of democracy
include the right to protection and freedom to communicate. People should
have the right to form their own opinions, thoughts and beliefs. But this
includes things that aren’t always acceptable in our society. Christian
church groups don’t want people to be exposed to religions they feel are
"evil", such as Satanism, and parents don’t want their kids to turn on
the television and view pornography. While most people agree with these
views, others (such as Satanists and pornographers) don’t find some of
these types of information objectionable, and feel they have the right
to this type of information. In a world where everyone is so different,
so filled with culture, it’s difficult to satisfy everyone’s needs.
History
Every society has had basic - usually unwritten - "rules" on what was
and was not acceptable for citizens to do, say, wear, and worship. Even
the ancient democratic city of Athens had censorship. When Socrates was
charged with worshipping false gods and corrupting the city’s youth, he
preferred to commit suicide than live without his intellectual freedom.
Later however, his student, Plato, ironically developed a rationale for
intellectual, religious, and artistic censorship, outlining an ideal -
censured - state in The Republic. Many well known philosophers had
all of their works destroyed. Despite these acts, Athens is still considered
a place where you could have spoken openly in private or public.
Meanwhile, in Rome, it was considered that only authorities could truly
speak freely. Authors of unacceptable works were punished, even banished
or burned alive. But the Roman Empire had to have some tolerance in order
to survive, as it ruled over nations of various religions and races. Jews
and Christians outside of the capital often refused to worship the imperial
figurehead (idolatry is against their respective religions), and were sometimes
persecuted, but all citizens inside Rome were required to.
Today
in North America
Today, most democratic countries, such as Canada and the United States,
have laws that allow the public to express themselves freely, as well as
laws that protect their citizens from information they are severely offended
by. But these laws often contradict each other. Courts are often faced
with the decision of whether someone’s right to communicate freely has
harmed someone. But there are regulations to prevent problems. In the case
of nude photography, North American publications often state their models
have reached the age of maturity, and vendors are not to sell such magazines
to children. Many schools avoid educational materials that discuss religion
or contain unnecessary objectionable material, such as sex, sometimes even
omitting sections of classic novels describing sex.
As the 20th century has progressed, North American society has become
more open and less conservative. When television became popular married
couples on classic family sit-coms slept in separate beds. Until the 1970’s
the US Postal Service refused to deliver certain This year Ellen DeGeneras
declared she was gay by "coming out" on the controversial hour long special
episode of her ABC comedy, Ellen. Also this year television networks
in the US began incorporating a content advisory system into their programming,
attaching a signal to the TV transmission that allowed special microchip
to block content parents might find unacceptable for their children to
view, and flashed a small ratings logo at the beginning of each show, something
that has already been done for movies and video and computer games.
Other
Countries
Citizens of democratic countries have many basic rights that are taken
for granted. These nations are not governed by religion, and a person’s
religious beliefs and forms of worship are their own choices. Meanwhile,
in communist countries citizens don’t have these rights. Atheism was the
standard ideology in the former USSR, and religion was rarely recognized
for anyone. In the 70’s Iran was quickly becoming "westernized", among
the most developed countries in the region, but a revolution quickly reinstituted
strict Islamic laws, and the country regressed.
Even England has had problems with censorship in its past, due to religious
control. In the 17th century a surveyor of the press had the power to prevent
information from being published, and publishing negative opinions of the
government became "seditious libel ".
In the late 1980’s a study conducted by Freedom House stated 2 billion
people on earth had high degrees of freedom, 1 billion had moderate freedom,
and 2.1 billion people lived in 68 countries that severely denied citizens
political and civil rights.
Current
Problems
While this decade will see many censorship barriers broken and more
progress in human rights, the 90’s have also brought a major problem: The
Internet. Anyone can communicate in Cyberspace, and anyone from any country
can access information originating in a different nation. So, what is acceptable
in some countries is not in others, and this has been a serious problem.
Not long ago, China even considered outlawing Internet access, and countries
like Germany are outraged at the content that is being distributed electronically.
Several "patchwork" solutions have been developed, such as software that
"filters" selected information, and RSAC (see link) ratings embedded in
HTML pages similar (including this site) to ratings used on movies, games,
and television. But because the Internet is a global place owned and governed
by nobody, true regulation is almost impossible. It is up to the individual
country to set guidelines on what is and isn’t acceptable, and governments
must co-operate in criminal investigations. When the United States proposed
its Communication Decency Act (CDA), many people of the online community
were outraged. Thousands put up blue ribbon logos on their websites to
voice their opposition to regulation, and hundreds of major sites "went
black" for a day, making their website black and white. The problem is
not expected to be solved anytime soon. |