The tale of fish


Apr. 23, 2009

The tale that carps jump over the dragon gate and the naked carps leap the dam.

 
Dragon dancing of carp in the myths and legends.   Dam jump of Naked carp of the Qinghai Lake.
Apr. 23, 2009

The tale of fish.

There has been a fascinating legend that carps in Yellow River would swim to the high Dragon Gate Mountain and those who, risking their lives, could leap the Gate would become dragons and would from then on lead a distinguished life of great reputation. While, now, in the Qinghai Lake of our hometown, there is a similar natural phenomenon: schools of fish are making continuous leaps, longing to jump over the towering dam in front of them to stay in the light waters on the opposite side.They try their best to jump What do they jump for? For turning out to be dragons?

Apr. 29, 2009

No, it’s not like that, because this is not a legend.

 
Just look at these lovely fish, they live in salty lakes, they have no scales, their bodies are smooth and they are called naked carps, also Huangyu.   They grow up slowly, just one tael for a year and only half a kilogram for ten years!And I tell you, the dam leaping is not a legend, it is a natural phenomenon.
Apr. 23, 2009

And I tell you, it is a natural phenomenon.

I realized that carps leaped because they wanted to lay eggs in the freshwater lakes on the other side of the damfrom a TV program which I watched several days ago.

Apr. 23, 2009

And I wonder!

I wonder why these naked carps must lay their eggs in the fresh water on that side. Couldn’t they just do that in the Qinghai Lake?


Apr. 23, 2009

The Qinghai Lake is a salty lake.

The Qinghai Lake is a salty lake, rich in salt and alkali.
I think it may be for this reason that the lake doesn’t fit the egg laying. The Qinghai Lake is only suitable for the grown-up naked carps while the fresh waters for them to lay eggs.

Apr. 29, 2009

The freshwater is more suitable for the eggs.

I understand from the internet that the fresh waters surrounding the Qinghai Lake is more suitable for the naked carps to lay eggs because of the low intensity of salt and alkali. Also, due to the particular landform, currents in the river flow in a stimulating way for the egg laying.


Apr. 23, 2009

Do all the carps succeed in jumb over dam?

Do all the carps succeed in leaping over the dam to lay eggs on the other side?My students, do you think they could make it? If they could, do all the eggs survive and grow up to be little carps?

Positions:

Yes, the carps could make it. (0)
A few of the carps could make. (4)

  • A few of the carps could make.

    If so, why not just dismantle the dams so that the carps could lay their eggs favorably?
    Apr. 23, 2009

     

  • A few of the carps could make.

    I think it is impossible for all the carps to leap the dam to lay eggs which can grow up and I know from a group of statistics from Qinghai Environmental Protection Net that in recent years, the number of carps in Qinghai Lake is decreasing: 7500 tons of them in 1995 and 5017 tons in 2004. As the quantity of naked carps is reducing, then accordingly, not all the eggs could grow up to adults.
    Apr. 23, 2009

     

  • A few of the carps could make.

    For the other reason, I have consulted several materials, according to which, those dams are over two meters high and it is not easy for the carps to jump over them. So I think not all the carps could leap over the dams to lay eggs on the other side.
    Apr. 23, 2009

     

  • A few of the carps could make.

    We have the introduction about fish eggs in the course of this semester: the Science. It says that the fish has an astonishing reproductive potential and carps lay almost 1.7 million eggs once. But the eggs demand suitable environment to grow up, yet in most conditions, only a small percentage of them could make it. So we know that only a slight quantity of carp eggs could survive. Then, this is one reason why we should choose the second item: Only a few of the carps and eggs could make it.
    Apr. 23, 2009

     

Apr. 23, 2009

Now let us discuss the opinions of Ziyu Shang

Student shangziyu suggests that the dam should be removed to the benefit for carps to lay eggs.Do you think it can be acceptable?

Positions:

I agree! (1)
I don’t agree, because… (3)

  • I agree!

    I am for the dismantling, because the dams seriously affect the carps’ reproduction.
    The decreasing number of naked carps not only fall in trouble themselves, but also wield an influence on birds there. This shows the ecological balance in the Qinghai Lake is damaged and the dams should be removed.
    Apr. 23, 2009

     

  • I don’t agree, because…

    Besides the obstruction of dams,there are other reasons to threaten the carps survival in the QingHai lake,such as the global warming and the unreasonable human behavior like illegal hunts of carps. The decrease in number of carps leads to the lessening birds’ varieties, which has a terrible influence upon the ecological balance of “coexistence of carps and birds” in Qinghai Lake. Then you know the dams are very important for the local agricultural irrigation. And I think this is what we call the ecological relationship among humans, carps and birds. So dimantling the dams is not a good solution to Qinghai Lake’s ecological problems.
    Apr. 23, 2009

     

  • I don’t agree, because…

    That is why I disagree with the dismantling. It is true that the dams hinder the egg laying, but we cannot let the dismantling affect local people’s lives.what’s more government has taken several measures, I believe the Qinghai Lake’s environment will be gradually improved.
    Apr. 23, 2009

     

  • I don’t agree, because…

    Those dams are built for the sake of water storage for people alongside the two banks to irrigate their crops, so the dismantling of dams will obstruct the local agriculture. Then the dams shouldn’t be torn down because this is neither the best nor the most effective solution. When confronted with a complex, we should take an overall view and try to seek out the most appropriate scheme instead of resorting to a makeshift solution.
    Apr. 23, 2009

     

Apr. 28, 2009

Our long-range cooperative learning.

   
The students in North Street primary school with us are cooperating on the internet to study.   This way to study makes us happy.