|
|
 |
THE DESCENDANTS OF TWO GIANTS
|
|
|
|
| |
THE DESCENDANTS OF TWO GIANTS
The last twenty-five years of the 20th century were full of
new surprises. A very new theory, known as String
Theory, emerged. This theory was originally
formulated to explain the phenomenon of scattering of
hadrons. There are various ways by which this
can be done. The process of scattering is described by
some graphs which are known as Feynman graphs
(you must have understood who had made them). They
give the space-time view of the process of scattering.
Scattering leads to the creation of new particles.
While analysis, these three processes were found to be
equivalent: |
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
They could not be same if one followed the conventional
processes of scattering with point-like particles. But, if
assumed that such structures were formed from string motion
into space-time, then the figures would become
topologically equivalent. This idea was proposed by Veneziano in 1968 and Yoichiro Nambu in 1970. This new
idea did not gain much attention during that time, but in
1980’s, the weaknesses of super-symmetry and the failure
of the standard model to unify gravity led to the
reintroduction of string theory in a new form
-
the Superstring. Superstring Theory is a background
based theory and needs the presence of a background space
which can be perturbed by small amounts to study the
effects. This theory has successfully unified gravity with
quantum mechanics, but has some strange characters like
having so many dimensions. A very successful result of the
theory is that gravity is a consequence of low energy
vibration of strings. Edward Witten, the leading string
theorist, considers it the most beautiful consequence of
the theory. The higher dimensions in string theory are
embedded in our universe themselves in small loops. Every
coordinate in the four dimension universe contains a
structure which contains the extra dimensions.
Another very important theory is that of Loop Quantum
Gravity Theory. This theory considers a discrete
nature of space-time at a level known as Planck Scale. Max
Planck had considered a scale in which speed of light,
Planck’s constant and gravitational constant are 1. The
unit of length in such a scale comes out to be around 10-34
metres and the unit of time, 10-43 seconds. It
is easy to derive that Planck length =
Ö(Gћ/c3).
While analyzing the relation between the actions of
relativity and of quantum level, it was found that they
became equivalent at the level of Planck scale. It is
impossible to study the effect of gravity without
introducing the quantum principles below this level. In loop
quantum gravity, at Planck level, the world becomes
quantized or composed of loops. There is no background
space; space is almost absent there and the whole metric
is present in the form of dirac-delta function on
these loops. It was found that these Planck scales must be
invariant under Lorentz transformation, which was not
allowed under relativity (length contraction). So a new
theory, Doubly Special Relativity, had to be
introduced where there were two invariants instead of one
- the Planck length and the speed of light. With these two
invariants, a new form of relativity theory has emerged
with a better promise of a ‘final law’. The leading
theorist, Lee Smolin, has played a very vital role in
developing the theory. He openly criticizes the very
abnormal characteristics of string theory (a big reason
why it has still been impossible to experimentally verify
it) and considers this a very big drawback of the theory,
even after the theory’s incredible success. The new
experimental accelerator (Large Hadron Collider), being
built in CERN, holds the promise of unveiling new
mysteries of the world and observing many still mysterious
particles like the Higgs Boson (a particle which
attributes mass to every other particle). A few years ago
(end of 1980’s), a very powerful particle accelerator
(Superconducting Super Collider) was proposed to be built,
which would put an end to almost all the troubles (it had
enough energy to produce the Higgs Boson). But, thanks to
the government’s budget policies, it was never built; Steven
Weinberg, in his book ‘Dreams Of A Final Theory’,
has given a clear account of the issue (he was among the
persons trying to persuade the government to pass the
bill). The estimated cost of production had reached 12
billion dollars and the project was finally cancelled
because the US could not afford this cost as well as the
cost of NASA’s research (again, Einstein’s realm came in
the path of quantum development).
|
There are other theories, like the Twistor Theory which
was developed by Roger Penrose in 1967. It is a
form of complexification of space-time, writing
space-time coordinates in terms of complex numbers.
So, there are two complex spaces and hence, four
real coordinates. Edward Witten has recently developed
a new form, Twistor String Theory. Another
development by Roger Penrose, Spin Network Theory, where
there are diagrams to represent the particle interactions,
is extensively used in loop quantum gravity theory. |
|
|
| |
Stephen Hawking is working similarly to develop something
called the Euclidean Quantum Theory. Here,
Riemannian manifold (the manifold in which the metric
signature is always positive) is used instead of
pseudo-Riemannian manifold (in which the metric signature
may be negative or zero, like in Minkowski space).
This is based on the concept of Wick Rotation. Wick
rotation converts Minkowski space in Euclidean space
by just making the time complex. It yields surprising
result, with quantum mechanical equations, which
becomes very much like the equations of statistical
mechanics under Wick rotation. You can consider the
universe to be made up of five dimensions, with two
dimensions of time (real and imaginary). So, time
is complexified and a simple rotation from our Minkowski
world, lying on real time axis, to imaginary time
axis will do the job.
Another theory is the Non-Commutative Geometry where
the geometry is non-commutative. The metric tensor
which is generally used is assumed to be symmetric
and hence, follows the commutativity rule (gij =
gji ). But, it is possible to have geometries
where this assumption is dropped. In non-commutative
geometry, the algebra defining the properties of
various quantities on the manifold looses commutativity.
These theories have been able to come up as promising theories
of quantum gravity, but they do not seem to care
much about the problems of the interpretation of
quantum mechanics. A complete theory must have this
property because more than having a theory which
has both quantum mechanics and relativity theory
as its consequences, it is necessary to have something
which can explain everything - not
just the interactions. Now, the quantum state reduction
is no longer the problem of quantum mechanics alone.
Even gravitational energy has much to do with it.
Also, the mysterious dark matter and dark energy
need the explanation. Many other recently observed
phenomena need explanations (like a very recent observation
of change in the speed of light). Probably, we must
wait for more experimental data (like those from
Large Hadron Collider); who knows, may be, another
Michelson-Morley experiment is going to take place
for another clerk in some far away land. |
|
|
|
|
| |
|
| |
|