|
|
| |
|
|
- Sulphur Dioxide
- A colourless gas when in high levels can cause
humans respiratory problems.
- Carbon Monoxide
- A toxic gas difficult to identify and is fatal
at high levels. Has been known to cause headaches
and impaired vision.
- Nitrogen Dioxide
- A gas that irritates the eye, nose and throat.
- Ground-level Ozone
- Causes respiratory problems from the mildest
(cough) to the most severe (aggravated asthma).
- Violate Organic Compounds
- Particulate Matter.(i.e. PM10/2.5)
- Made up of fine particles that can cause a range
of respiratory and heart problems depending on
the size of the particles.
Particulate matter is basically particles of solids
or droplets of liquid. They are sometimes emitted directly
from a source or are formed when pollutants in the atmosphere
react with each other. These particles come in a wide
range of sizes. Those that are smaller than 10 micrometers
(i.e. PM10) are potentially harmful to our health for
they can get into our lungs to do some serious damage.
These PM10 particles actually damage human health and
could cause many different respiratory effects on us.
Also, these PM10 are produced from the haze with the
many minute particles of dust and smog suspended in
the air during the haze.
|
| |
|
| |
Back to Top
|
In
order to measure the amount of pollutants in the air
of a certain place, indexes are essential to enable
environmentalists to express the degree of pollution
in a way that is universally understood. With the indexes,
media sources will be able to report air quality daily
and enable the public to be aware of the air pollution
levels. Across the globe, several types of air pollutant
indexes exist. Here we will be introducing a few indexes
used in SEA countries and other countries.
SNO |
Index
Currently Used |
Countries |
1 |
PSI |
Singapore, Taiwan |
2 |
AQI |
US, Canada |
3 |
API |
Hong Kong, Malaysia
|
4 |
ISPU |
Indonesia |
|
Back to Top
|
Singapore
uses PSI to keep track of air quality. According to
e-notes.com,
it does so by ※measuring the concentrations of pollutants
in the air, in parts per million§.
The table below describes the general health effects
for the various levels of air pollution.
PSI |
Descriptor |
General
Health Effects |
0
每 50 |
Good |
None |
51
每 100 |
Moderate |
Few
or none for the general
population |
101
每 200 |
Unhealthy |
Mild
aggravation of symptoms among susceptible
persons
- those with underlying conditions such as chronic
heart or lung ailments; transient symptoms of
irritation
- eye irritation, sneezing or coughing in some
of the healthy population
|
201
每 300 |
Very
unhealthy |
Moderate
aggravation of symptoms
Decreased tolerance in persons
with heart or lung disease
More widespread symptoms of transient
irritation in the healthy population |
301
每 400 |
Hazardous |
Early
onset of certain diseases in addition
to significant aggravation of symptoms
in susceptible persons
Decreased exercise tolerance
in healthy persons |
401
每 500 |
Extremely
Hazardous |
Life-threatening
to ill and elderly people
Healthy people may experience adverse
symptoms that affect normal activity |
Fig 1.1 taken from http://app.nea.gov.sg/cms/htdocs/article.asp?pid=1251with
permission.
The PSI was developed by the United States Environmental
Protection Agency (USEPA). It incorporates
only particulate matter smaller than 10 (PM10). In 1999,
US EPA changed the PSI to the AQI so that it will be
more accurate in calculating PM2.5 and ozone gases rather
than just PM10. |
Back
to Top
|
According
to Wikipedia, the AQI is also an indicator
of air quality at a specific place. It measures mainly
the ground-level ozone and volatile organic compounds
(VOCs) in the presence of sunlight§, which is brought
about by mainly human activities. It is mainly used
in the US and Canada. Particulates (fine particles of
either solid or liquid suspended in the air) may also
include sulphur dioxide and nitrogen dioxide, a gas
poisonous to inhale, but is still a common air pollutant.
According to AirNow,
A cross-agency U.S. Government Web site, AQI is divided
into the following 6 categories, differented by colors.
Index |
Status |
Description |
0
to 50 |
Good
|
Acceptable
air quality; minimal risks |
51
to 100 |
Moderate
|
Largely
acceptable, poses risk to a minority |
101
to 150 |
Unhealthy
for Sensitive Groups |
Sensitive
people may run into respiratory problems |
151
to 200 |
Unhealthy |
Population
experiences health problems; sensitive groups
may run into serious problems |
201
to 300 |
Very
Unhealthy |
Health
alert stage. All may experience severe health
problems |
301
to 500 |
Hazardous |
State
of emergency would be declared. All will be affected. |
Fig 2.1 modified from http://www.airnow.gov/index.cfm?action=aqibroch.aqi#2
with permission.
|
Back
to Top
|
Let
us now compare the difference between the two indexes
discussed so far, the AQI and PSI.
AQI |
PSI |
More
sensitive 〞 includes particulates that are only
larger or around 2.5 micrometers |
Less
sensitive 〞 includes particulates which are larger
of around 10 micrometers |
Used
mainly by US and Canada |
In
several countries such as the United States and
Singapore |
More
for research purposes
(for environmentalists to get a better understanding
/ idea of pollutants present in the air; help
in research) |
Used
because government wants to let citizens be aware
of the state of pollution of air.
Easier for media broadcasting |
|
Back
to Top
|
Air
Pollution Index (API) is used in Hong Kong
and Malaysia. It measures the amount of the 4 main greenhouses
gases (sulphur dioxide, carbon monoxide, ozone and nitrogen
dioxide) in a day based on the possible health effects
of air pollutants.
When level(s) of the pollutant(s) bridge(s) the healthy
range, the indicator would rise to 100 or above. Advice
pertaining to precautionary actions would then be disseminated
to public by the Hong Kong Environmental Protection
Department.
API |
Air
Pollution Level |
Health
Problems |
Action
Plan |
0
每 25 |
Low |
Not
expected |
No
response needed |
26
每 50 |
Medium |
Not
expected for the general
population |
51
每 100 |
High |
Acute
health effects are not expected, but
chronic effects may be observed if one is persistently
exposed to such levels of air pollution |
No
immediate response needed; detrimental effects
may be seen in the long run |
100
每 200 |
Very
High |
People
with existing heart or respiratory illnesses may
notice mild aggravation of their health
conditions
Generally healthy individuals may also notice
some discomfort |
Population
with medical condition is advised to refrain from
physical activities; general population is advised
to refrain from forceful physical activities |
201
每 500 |
Very
High |
People
with existing heart or respiratory illnesses may
experience significant aggravation of
their symptoms.
There may be widespread symptoms
in the healthy population like
- eye irritation
- wheezing
- coughing
- phlegm
- sore throats
|
General
population should refrain from physical actives
and population with medical condition(s) should
take extra care/ |
Fig 3.1 modified from http://cleanair.hk/eng/air_pollution.htm,
with permission.
The Air Pollution Index is also used in Malaysia. However,
the API Structure in Malaysia differs from that used
in Hong Kong. Four of this index*s components are measured
in parts per million by volume. They are carbon monoxide,
ozone, sulphur dioxide and nitrogen dioxide. The Malaysian
API can exceed 500. When it reaches this level, a state
of emergency is declared in the affected area.
The table below shows the API Status indicator
used in Malaysia.
API
Status Indicator
|
API |
Status |
|
0-50 |
Good |
|
51-100 |
Moderate |
|
101-200 |
Unhealthy |
|
201-300 |
Very unhealthy |
|
301-500 |
Hazardous |
|
Above
500 |
Emergency |
|
Back
to Top
|
Let
us now compare the difference between the two indexes
discussed so far, the AQI and PSI.
API |
AQI |
Measures
the 4 main Greenhouse gases |
Measures
particulates that are only larger or around 2.5
micrometers |
Used
mainly by Malaysia and Hong Kong |
Used
mainly in US and Canada |
Takes
into consideration major pollutants which include
sulphur dioxide, nitrogen dioxide, carbon monoxide,
ozone, particulates and violate organic compounds.
However, focuses on the main 4. |
More
for research purposes
(for environmentalists to get a better understanding
/ idea of pollutants present in the air; help
in research) |
|
Back
to Top
|
(Translated,
it means: Indonesia's Standard Air Pollution Index or
Standard Air Pollution Index)
The ISPU is used by Indonesia in calculating the haze
level. It basically takes into consideration 3 major
pollutants that affect air quality which are namely:
ozone, sulphur dioxide and PM10. The crux of the ISPU
is that it shows the air quality of major air pollutants
and its potential threat to the general population*s
health in one reading. Two other air quality indicators
are also included, Ground Level Ozone and Toxic Air
Release, but Ground level Ozone is reported separately
due to changes in regulations regarding it.
ISPU |
Band |
0
每 50 |
Good |
51
每 100 |
Moderate |
101
每 199 |
Unhealthy |
200
每 299 |
Very
Unhealthy |
300
and higher |
Hazardous |
Fig 4.1 generated form data gathered at http://www.theharbinger.org/xviii/000411/envision1.html
Acknowledgements
We had some difficulties in researching about ISPU and
we posted a question on Yahoo! Answers. Big thanks to
rynkiedink
of Yahoo!Answers for providing us with the links and
information. We would like to suggest that the Indonesian
government be more transparent and release ISPU readings
to the public (i.e. English Website [something which
we could not find])
- Perhaps the government should be more transparent
and release information to
the public (i.e. English Website [something which
we could not find])
- Through this, researchers will then be able to gain
more information about the
situation and hence, be able to conduct more research.
|
Back
to Top |
After
researching the four pollutant indexes above, we are
aware that there are other indexes in use across the
globe that we have not explored. Our team then had a
question in mind 〞 why do people in all over the world
have to create so many different indexes to measure
air quality? We felt that if we could have one single,
standardized index that would be used throughout all
the countries, then it would make work easier for both
the citizens and professionals (environmentalists, researchers,
scientists). There would then be no more confusion between
people of different nationality who want to know the
air quality in each others country.
Therefore, we felt that it definitely would be excellent
if the governments or rulers of all countries arrange
to come together to develop and agree on a standardized
air quality index to facilitate the measurement of air
quality in their respective countries.
Index |
Area
of Focus |
PSI |
PM10,
media broadcasting |
AQI |
PM2.5,
more sensitive |
API |
4
major pollutants (carbon monoxide, sulphur dioxide,
nitrogen dioxide and ozone) |
ISPU |
Potential
threat to general population*s health
Considers 3 main pollutants 每 Ozone, PM10 and
Sulphur Dioxide |
|
Back to Top
|
| |
|